Update Externals.cfg to cesm2_3_beta17 and remove mct #2539
Task list completed / task-list-completed
Started
2024-05-28 22:09:19
ago
5 / 6 tasks completed
1 task still to be completed
Details
Required Tasks
| Task | Status |
|---|---|
| For the SETUP failure above, bisect between ccs_config_cesm0.0.92 and 106 until I find where it first fails. Note: | Incomplete |
| This test was expected to fail in SHAREDLIB_BUILD | Incomplete |
| the SETUP error starts with version 99 | Incomplete |
| Try similar approach for all the failures: | Incomplete |
| On izumi it's probably cmeps | |
| cmeps0.14.50 PASS | |
| cmeps0.14.51 FAIL new error | Incomplete |
| For FUNIT, I had to bring back a CMakeLists.txt file that I had removed | Incomplete |
| For LILAC, this far I have confirmed that it's not ccs_config (by running with version 99 as above) and that it's not cime (by running cime6.0.217_httpsbranch03); I backed out various changes and continued to get the same error; Erik suggested this, but I still got the same error. Jim E. posted that I should not have removed mct, so I will reverse that commit and try again. | |
| (UPDATE about LILAC appears below, based on which version 99 here is not likely a typo, and I may have confused myself with these earlier tests.) | Incomplete |
| I thought you would checkout the branch from the PR | Incomplete |
| Instead you ended up with my cmeps0.14.50 test, which passes | Incomplete |
| Copy my Externals.cfg again to get it with cmeps0.14.60 | |
| Now I would expect the failure to repeat. | Incomplete |
| In my local branch I have reverted the removal of /src/cpl/mct and I am ready to push to here | Incomplete |
| Do you need me to revert anything else mct-related or other? | Incomplete |
| Also to confirm beyond doubt: the instruction to remove mct that I followed in this post was mistaken? | Incomplete |
| PASS Test with ctsm5.2.004 (no change) OR change all externals except keep ccs_config version 92 or 93 or 94 | Incomplete |
| FAIL Change all externals except keep ccs_config version 95 | Incomplete |
| FAIL with same error, tests with cf1a297 (change all externals) and later (ccce061, db147cd, 3d1ab9b) | Incomplete |
| PASS Change all externals except keep ccs_config version 94 | Incomplete |
| FAIL Change all externals except keep ccs_config version 95. This failing test is here: | |
/glade/derecho/scratch/slevis/LILACSMOKE_D_Ld2.f10_f10_mg37.I2000Ctsm50NwpSpAsRs.derecho_intel.clm-lilac.C.20240517_144532_pmf0rk |
|
| Code is here: /glade/work/slevis/git/latest_master | |
| git branch: upd_externals_to_beta17 | |
| git describe: ctsm5.2.004-19-ge4544510e | |
| git diff: | Incomplete |
| @slevis-lmwg did you put some workaround in place? | Incomplete |
| Could it be a difference in our environments? | Incomplete |
| Could it be a difference between running this as a single test vs. a test suite? | Incomplete |
| Unfortunately it failed for me again in aux_clm as before: | |
| /glade/work/slevis/git/latest_master/tests_0521-114730de/LILAC... | |
| I compared my CaseDocs to yours and nothing jumped out as strange. | |
In the same directory I saved LILAC_dif_from_billsacks.out which compares my test directory for this test against yours. A few differences stand out, but ones for which I do not know the meaning. |
Incomplete |
| Then I tried the way that you submitted the test: | |
./run_sys_tests --walltime 0:30:00 -t LILACSMOKE_D_Ld2.f10_f10_mg37.I2000Ctsm50NwpSpAsRs.derecho_intel.clm-lilac --skip-compare --skip-generate and it failed the same way. |
Incomplete |
| Then I added the -V line to machines/config_batch.xml (as discussed earlier in this PR) and tried rerunning the test three different ways: | Incomplete |
| The way you did: PASS | Incomplete |
| From ./create_test: PASS | Incomplete |
From the aux_clm test directory that had originally failed. I even tried ./case.build --clean-all followed by ./case.build, but it didn't work. |
Incomplete |
| Erik got the same error that I get when running without the -V option. I feel some kind of selfish relief from that result. | Incomplete |
| Bill, I ran this test without the -V option (I hope I didn't misunderstand and run the opposite case than the one you requested): | |
/glade/derecho/scratch/SMS_Ln9.f10_f10_mg37.I1850Clm45Bgc.derecho_intel.clm-clm45cam4LndTuningModeZDustSoilErod.20240522_171510_yc8o9d |
Incomplete |
| Sam's failing LILAC test (run without -V) | Incomplete |
| Sam's passing LILAC test (run WITH -V) | Incomplete |
| Sam's passing SMS test (run without -V) | Incomplete |
| My passing LILAC test (run without -V: for some reason it passes for me even though it fails for Sam) | Incomplete |
| share1.0.18: now both tests appear DIFF from baseline again. I now see that I confused myself last week into thinking that this was fixed. I likely forgot to rerun ./manage_externals/checkout_externals after bisecting. | Incomplete |
| cmeps0.14.50: the f45 test is DIFF from ctsm5.2.005 and the diffs are identical when using cmeps0.14.63 | Incomplete |
| ccs_config_cesm0.0.98: the f45 test FAILs to build | Incomplete |
| ctsm5.2.005 Externals.cfg except keep ccs_config_ccsm0.0.106 and mizuRoute: the f45 test is DIFF from ctsm5.2.005 and the diffs are identical with ctsm5.2.006 Externals.cfg | Incomplete |
| One reference I see with "git grep -i mct" that I think should be removed is: | Completed |
| The changes to src/main/glc2lndMod.F90 I mention | Completed |
| I've outlined more that I think should be done here in #2279. | Completed |
| Remove the src/cpl/mct directory and it's entire contents | Completed |
| Looks like there are still outstanding tests failing, that should be gotten to work | Incomplete |
| Remove cime_config/testdefs/testmods_dirs/clm/nuopc_cap_bfb directory | Completed |
Loading