diff --git a/lib/valkyrie/storage/disk.rb b/lib/valkyrie/storage/disk.rb
index 87975ea7..4d012e61 100644
--- a/lib/valkyrie/storage/disk.rb
+++ b/lib/valkyrie/storage/disk.rb
@@ -18,7 +18,19 @@ def upload(file:, original_filename:, resource: nil, **_extra_arguments)
       new_path = path_generator.generate(resource: resource, file: file, original_filename: original_filename)
       FileUtils.mkdir_p(new_path.parent)
       file_mover.call(file.path, new_path)
-      find_by(id: Valkyrie::ID.new("disk://#{new_path}"))
+
+      identifier = id_for(file: file, original_filename: original_filename, resource: resource)
+      find_by(id: identifier)
+    end
+
+    # @param file [IO]
+    # @param original_filename [String]
+    # @param resource [Valkyrie::Resource]
+    # @param _extra_arguments [Hash] additional arguments which may be passed to other adapters
+    # @return [Valkyrie::ID]
+    def id_for(file:, original_filename:, resource: nil, **_extra_arguments)
+      new_path = path_generator.generate(resource: resource, file: file, original_filename: original_filename)
+      Valkyrie::ID.new("disk://#{new_path}")
     end
 
     # @param id [Valkyrie::ID]
diff --git a/lib/valkyrie/storage/fedora.rb b/lib/valkyrie/storage/fedora.rb
index 6957942c..1ecddc70 100644
--- a/lib/valkyrie/storage/fedora.rb
+++ b/lib/valkyrie/storage/fedora.rb
@@ -36,7 +36,10 @@ def find_by(id:)
     # @return [Valkyrie::StorageAdapter::StreamFile]
     def upload(file:, original_filename:, resource:, content_type: "application/octet-stream", # rubocop:disable Metrics/ParameterLists
                resource_uri_transformer: default_resource_uri_transformer, **_extra_arguments)
+
+      # we can't use id_for here because this id requires furhter transformation below
       identifier = resource_uri_transformer.call(resource, base_url) + '/original'
+
       sha1 = [5, 6].include?(fedora_version) ? "sha" : "sha1"
       connection.http.put do |request|
         request.url identifier
@@ -48,9 +51,23 @@ def upload(file:, original_filename:, resource:, content_type: "application/octe
         io = Faraday::UploadIO.new(file, content_type, original_filename)
         request.body = io
       end
+
       find_by(id: Valkyrie::ID.new(identifier.to_s.sub(/^.+\/\//, PROTOCOL)))
     end
 
+    # @param file [IO]
+    # @param original_filename [String]
+    # @param resource [Valkyrie::Resource]
+    # @param content_type [String] content type of file (e.g. 'image/tiff') (default='application/octet-stream')
+    # @param resource_uri_transformer [Lambda] transforms the resource's id (e.g. 'DDS78RK') into a uri (optional)
+    # @param extra_arguments [Hash] additional arguments which may be passed to other adapters
+    # @return [Valkyrie::StorageAdapter::StreamFile]
+    def id_for(file:, original_filename:, resource:, content_type: "application/octet-stream", # rubocop:disable Metrics/ParameterLists
+               resource_uri_transformer: default_resource_uri_transformer, **_extra_arguments)
+      identifier = resource_uri_transformer.call(resource, base_url) + '/original'
+      Valkyrie::ID.new(identifier.to_s.sub(/^.+\/\//, PROTOCOL))
+    end
+
     # Delete the file in Fedora associated with the given identifier.
     # @param id [Valkyrie::ID]
     def delete(id:)
diff --git a/lib/valkyrie/storage/memory.rb b/lib/valkyrie/storage/memory.rb
index 6f102b16..980fd752 100644
--- a/lib/valkyrie/storage/memory.rb
+++ b/lib/valkyrie/storage/memory.rb
@@ -16,10 +16,19 @@ def initialize
     # @param _extra_arguments [Hash] additional arguments which may be passed to other adapters
     # @return [Valkyrie::StorageAdapter::StreamFile]
     def upload(file:, original_filename:, resource: nil, **_extra_arguments)
-      identifier = Valkyrie::ID.new("memory://#{resource.id}")
+      identifier = id_for(file: file, original_filename: original_filename, resource: resource)
       cache[identifier] = Valkyrie::StorageAdapter::StreamFile.new(id: identifier, io: file)
     end
 
+    # @param file [IO]
+    # @param original_filename [String]
+    # @param resource [Valkyrie::Resource]
+    # @param _extra_arguments [Hash] additional arguments which may be passed to other adapters
+    # @return [Valkyrie::StorageAdapter::StreamFile]
+    def id_for(file:, original_filename:, resource: nil, **_extra_arguments)
+      Valkyrie::ID.new("memory://#{resource.id}")
+    end
+
     # Return the file associated with the given identifier
     # @param id [Valkyrie::ID]
     # @return [Valkyrie::StorageAdapter::StreamFile]