diff --git a/Maccy/Menu.swift b/Maccy/Menu.swift
index f9b60d34..c94789d2 100644
--- a/Maccy/Menu.swift
+++ b/Maccy/Menu.swift
@@ -367,11 +367,7 @@ class Menu: NSMenu, NSMenuDelegate {
 
       updateUnpinnedItemsVisibility()
       setKeyEquivalents(historyMenuItems)
-
-      let mainItemToHighlightIndex = historyItemToRemoveIndex - 1
-      if items.count >= mainItemToHighlightIndex {
-        highlight(items[mainItemToHighlightIndex])
-      }
+      highlight(items[historyItemToRemoveIndex])
     }
   }