Empty form fields are missing from the model obgect

[AviFix]

Hi,

When leaving a field empty, its property seems to be removed from the form value.

Regular angular form:

firstName is empty but is exist

ngx-schema-form:

email is empty and not showing in the model object.

Thanks

[daniele-pecora]

That is true, but how could it be handled otherwise and maintain the required validation?

[AviFix]

What do you mean?
Does it contradict?

[daniele-pecora]

Partially it does, because required wouldn't trigger if field is empty, only triggers if field is not present.

[AviFix]

Isn't it possible to trigger the required if the field is empty like the angular form control does?

[daniele-pecora]

ngx-schema-form doesn't rely on angular form control validation rather on a json schema validator.
The default validator implementation is Z-Schema.
JSON Schema validation counts an empty property as present and therefore the required rule is passed as 'valid'.
A 'required' validation is negative only if the required property is not present at all.

[AviFix]

Thanks for the detailed explanation.

Could you please point me to the code that is in charge of removing the empty fields and to the validation part?

[daniele-pecora]

I don't know it myself.
For preventing a huge breaking change this should end in a feature that can optionally be activated.
Maybe via forRoot(...) or smt else

[AviFix]

Sure

Anyone else that can point me toi the code that is in charge of removing the empty fields and to the validation?

[daniele-pecora]

@AviFix I would guess that widget.ts could be a good start (just guessing)