-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 97
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Issues with the designation of BA.4 and BA.5 #645
Comments
Things are keeping to be problematic. |
Thanks @shay671 for looking into this and providing the queries. If possible, can you run pangolin in the default UShER mode with the Also, it seems that two months after the release of pangolin v4.0 with UShER as the default analysis mode and an assignment cache option to compensate for UShER being slower than pangoLEARN, GISAID is still using pangoLEARN for assignments. I'm hoping that if multiple community members ask GISAID to use pangolin v4's UShER mode and assignment caches (with |
Hi @AngieHinrichs |
Hi @shay671 i noticed in your list C27889T as defining mutation in BA.5, i have spotted a few BA.5 sequences which dont carry 27889T but 27889C (as BA.4): most of them are for sure base calling to reference for sequencing issue but one portuguese sublineage could be real : https://nextstrain.org/fetch/genome.ucsc.edu/trash/ct/subtreeAuspice1_genome_3ac76_30e1d0.json?branchLabel=aa%20mutations&c=gt-nuc_27889&label=nuc%20mutations:C1912T,C2232T,C3317T,T3358C |
I think this has been more or less fixed recently. |
In an analysis I did with @talyash, we found some discrepancies in the BA.4 and BA.5 samples found in Pango compared to other methods.
We took the samples that were designated BA.4/BA.5 In CovSpectrum and add to samples found using a particular queries we made for BA.4 and BA.5 (explained later).
All samples were run through USHER and Nextclade, and Pango online platforms.
Full results :
BA.4 BA.5 Analysis.xlsx
The results in the combined cohort (CovSpectrum designated + particular query) :
Found as BA.4 -
Query 1502 - (1331 found in Pango)
USHER – 1481 - (1329 found in Pango)
NextClade – 1472 (1320 found in Pango)
Pango – 1331
BA.5
Query – 951 (747 found in Pango)
USHER -934 (745 found in Pango)
NextClade- 951 (found 748 in Pango)
Pango – 757 (8 were exclusive to Pango from all other methods)
The queries for BA.4 and BA.5 are designed to take in the count for each variant :
Mutations found in the Variant and BA.2
Mutations that are found in BA.2 but reversed in the Variant
Mutations that found in BA.4 and BA.5 but not in BA.2
Mutations that were found only in BA.4 or BA.5
Query used for BA.4 :
[1-of: G27788T, C28724T, [1-of: A686-,A687-,G688-,T689-,C690-,A691-,T692-,T693-,T694-]]&[3-of: G27788T, C28724T, [1-of:A686-,A687-,G688-,T689-,C690-,A691-,T692-,T693-,T694-],G12160A,T22917G,T23018G]&![2-of:C9866T,A23040G]&[3-of:C26858T,A27259C,G27382C,A27383T,T27384C]&[33-of:C241T,G4184A,A9424G,C14408T,C23525T,A24424T,C10198T,C17410T,A18163G,A22786C,G27382C,C3037T,C12880T,T22200G,A28271T,C10449A,A27383T,A23055G,A23063T,T22679C,C10029T,C22674T,G22992A,T27384C,C15714T,G22775A,C21618T,T24469A,C26060T,C26858T,C27807T,C28311T,A29510C,T670G,C2790T,C9344T,A20055G,C22686T,C22995A,A23013C,G23948T,G28882A,C4321T,C23604A,C25584T,G28881A,A22688G,A23403G,T23075C,C23854A,C26270T,G26709A,C9534T,G22578A,T22882G,C25000T,C26577G,G10447A,G22813T,T23599G,G28883C,C19955T,G21987A,A27259C,[1-of:T11288-,C11289-,T11290-,G11291-,G11292-,T11293-,T11294-,T11295-,T11296-],[1-of:T21633-,A21634-,C21635-,C21636-,C21637-,C21638-,C21639-,T21640-,G21641-,T21765-,A21766-,C21767-,A21768-,T21769-,G21770-],[1-of:G28362-,A28363-,G28364-,A28365-,A28366-,C28367-,G28368-,C28369-,A28370-]]
Query used for BA.5
[1-of: G26529A,C27889T]&[3-of: G12160A,T22917G,T23018G,G26529A,C27889T]&![2-of: C9866T,A23040G,C26858T,A27259C,G27382C,A27383T,T27384C]&[30-of: C10449A,G21987A,T22882G,C26270T,A28271T,G22578A,A23403G,C25000T,C12880T,C28311T,C15714T,C17410T,G22775A,A22786C,G4184A,A9424G,A20055G,C22995A,A23063T,G23948T,C22686T,G22992A,C23525T,G28881A,T670G,A24424T,C2790T,A23055G,C9534T,C19955T,T23075C,T23599G,C26577G,G28883C,A29510C,C23854A,T24469A,C26060T,G26709A,G10447A,T22200G,C3037T,C21618T,A22688G,G22813T,C27807T,C241T,C10198T,A18163G,C25584T,C4321T,C9344T,T22679C,A23013C,G28882A,C10029T,C14408T,C22674T,C23604A,[1-of: T11288-,C11289-,T11290-,G11291-,G11292-,T11293-,T11294-,T11295-,T11296-],[1-of: T21633-,A21634-,C21635-,C21636-,C21637-,C21638-,C21639-,T21640-,G21641-,T21765-,A21766-,C21767-,A21768-,T21769-,G21770-],[1-of:G28362-,A28363-,G28364-,A28365-,A28366-,C28367-,G28368-,C28369-,A28370-]]
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: